Film and TV

Ready Player One – Film Review

by on 05/04/2018
Details
 
Director

Steven Spielberg

Writer

Zak Penn and Ernest Cline

Starring

Tye Sheridan, Olivia Cooke, Ben Mendelsohn, Lena Waithe, Simon Pegg, and Mark Rylance

Positives

Visually Stunning
Great mix of CGI and Live action
Engaging
Quite emotionally charged
Nerdtastic

Negatives

No Rush!
Shame that certain Book references weren't in it

Editor Rating
Total Score


Bottom Line
 

A must see film, from a must read book… Another Spielberg Classic  

 

Ready Player One is one of my favourite books, provided to me by Geek Pride’s very own Ben Fee at the dawning of Geek Pride and something I honestly feel pushed me into embracing my Nerdom 100% instead of hiding it in the shadows.

It is a nostalgia trip par excellence and a book that feels like it was written just for you. … in fact one of my first reviews for this very site (7 years ago!) was for Ready Player One (READ IT HERE), so finding out there was a film being made, and my one of the Gods of Nerd Film himself, Stephen Spielberg, very much interested me; if making me also somewhat apprehensive.

Just an FYI, there will be spoilers for the book and the film therefore if you want to read or watch Ready Player One then best stop reading now.

Right so first things first, if you are looking for a film that stays true to the book then you won’t get it sadly. This is very much a streamlined version with a lot of exposition taken out and changes made. There are slight nods, ‘Easter Eggs’ and references but it is it’s own beast and you will need to make your peace with that or else it will cause you conflict…. Game of Thrones book lovers, I’m looking at you.

I’ll list out some of the changes for you below, though note it has been 6 or 7 years since I read the book so excuse me if it’s not comprehensive.

  1. A lot of the exposition is gone. Wades, real life and the real world, his school ( which is in the Oasis) , Wades learning about all things Halliday, how he makes money and the friendship between Morrow and Halliday.
  2. A lot of the movie references from the book are gone, especially Blade Runner which plays a big part.
  3. The first two quests are changed, with the first, in the book, having Wade defeat a Dungeons & Dragons quest “The Tomb of Horrors” ( replaced in the film by a Race) and the second having them complete a game of Zork, replete with Blade Runner reference and Rush trivia ( replaced with The Shining )
  4. Rush and Joust, being part of the quests in the book are therefore gone from the film, slightly referenced at the end but not even a Rush song in the sound track.
  5. Morrows role in the book is a more bit pronounced and they all meet in his home, where he gives them equipment , headsets and suits to defeat the Sixers in the last battle. In the film he isn’t in it much but there is a nice twist to that…

So, as you can see there is a lot of differences, to the point that the exterior shell, the main plot line and end goal are the same as the book but the arteries, organs, pathways and inner works of that plot line and end goal are very different indeed….

The Questions are, Why? And does it matter?

Well the ‘Why’ I can only hazard a guess:

  • Exposition wise I’d say that if you are trying to cram all of the book into one film you’d struggle and so getting rid of peripheral things is necessary; unless you were making a trilogy which I don’t think would have worked here.
  • As for the lack of certain movie references, I feel this simply down to licensing; look how long it took Marvel to get Spider-Man from Sony and also I don’t think Spielberg wanted to have a self indulgent, “look at me” sort of film.
  • The change in quests, as annoying as they were, I’d put down to Dungeons and Dragons, Rush, Joust and especially Zork being very old school and niche references to an older audience and ones that might have gone over the head modern Nerd / norm who may have heard of these things but had little or no experience of them. The Race and the Shinning quests were ways to placate Geeks and enfranchise your average Jo public into the film. In the end had it been as obscure as some of the references in the books a lot of people might not have enjoyed it and I guess that brings us to the “Does it Matter?”

Well for a man who spends a lot of time moaning about things not being like the books you’d think it would but, despite initial disappointment in certain parts of the book not being there, I was overcome by the more modern and contemporaneous references and found myself being carried away by it all. It was a romp, funny, sad, tense and spectacular and they still had enough from the book to keep me happy but added to it with reams of additional nerdy references ( old and new) that I honesty think I’d need a few more viewings to pick up on:

  • The magic words spoken are from Excalibur
  • Halo, Elites and Spartans
  • Street Fighter characters, Chun Li, Blanka, Ryu
  • Overwatch characters
  • Deathstroke
  • Freddy
  • Commander Shepherd
  • Joker, Cat Woman, Batman, Batgirl Harley Quinn
  • Battle Toads
  • Jim Raynor from Starcraft
  • Minecraft
  • Marvin the Martian
  • The Iron Giant
  • The Serenity
  • The Akira Bike
  • The Delorean from Back to the Future
  • A Gundam
  • Mecha Godzilla
  • The pulse Rifle from Aliens
  • The Lancer from Gears of War
  • The Holy Hand Grenade

And I’m sure there were so many more!

I can see that there will be book lovers out there, especially older Geeks like myself who are going to be disappointed about the changes but personally, in answer to the question, does it matter? No it doesn’t… at all and having been a proponent of Geek Culture for years now I can honestly say, to paraphrase the Dark Knight (and alter it slightly), “it’s the film that geeks deserve, not need”

Strong words indeed but I loved it, so much so that I found myself getting quite anxious towards the end and even somewhat emotional; which was strange. I’ve seen a lot of Nerdy Films but for some reason this one, like the Book, encapsulated what it is like to be a Geek, both positives and negatives, from friendship and connection to addiction and reality. It’s lesson that being a Geek is hard and awkward and some times you just want to hide from reality is encapsulated by Halliday and is a mirror on ourselves and how a lot of us feel.

Add this to the underlying morals about: regret, seizing the moment, embracing real life from time to time and even Internet neutrality and you have something for everyone here. Book reader or not, Geek or Norm, Ready Player One, the Film, is not Elitist, it enfranchises, wows and carries you along on a story that a lot of us, in different ways, can relate to.

A must see film, from a must read book… Another Spielberg Classic

Watch us talk about it on our Podcast here:

Comments

comments